Monday, February 23, 2009

Will Copyright Laws Get The Best of YouTube?


Virtually anyone who has been living on this planet for the last four years knows that YouTube is one of the most popular and successful websites on the internet.  The website is a video sharing site where users can view, share and upload an unlimited number of videos.  Videos can consist of TV clips, music videos, video blogging, original short films and any video footage users want to share with the world. 

The site, created in February 2005, has since been purchased by Google Inc. for $1.65 billion.  It is now the third most visited website on the internet behind Google and Yahoo!.   People watch hundreds of millions of videos each day.  Currently, it is estimated that ten hours of video is uploaded to YouTube each minute.  The amount of traffic to the site draws many advertisers.  YouTube’s popularity has made them very profitable through their advertising power.  The format of the site allows them to offer a wide variety of advertising options.  Advertisers can run their own video ads, sponsor contests, create their own brand channels or add original content to the site.   

The freedom YouTube allows its users in uploading unlimited video has caused some legal issues for the website.  Users have been uploading copyrighted material to the site without paying royalties to the copyright holder.  This has been the cause of recent lawsuits against the website.  One of the most publicized of these lawsuits came from Viacom, an American media conglomerate, which owns MTV Netowrks, BET, VH-1, Comedy Central, Nickelodeon, Paramount Pictures, DreamWorks and MTV Films to name a few. 

Viacom sued YouTube in 2007, accusing them of “massive intentional copyright infringement.”  Viacom sued for 160,000 unauthorized Viacom clips uploaded to YouTube.  These videos were viewed 1.5 billion times at the time the lawsuit was brought against YouTube.  The Digital Millenium Copyright Act of 1998 was no defense for YouTube, but the judge ruled that Viacom could not seek punitive damages.  Instead, Viacom was able to solicit valuable data about YouTube users.  The court ruled that YouTube had to turn over IP addresses, user names and viewing history of all Viacom videos on the site. 

Later, Viacom and YouTube came to an agreement that allowed YouTube to keep the identities of its users anonymous.  Viacom was already on the defense for invading the privacy of online users so this agreement made Viacom look like a more responsible company.  For YouTube, this agreement kept its users somewhat happier in the situation because they were all kept anonymous.  The names and addresses were not the essential information that was useful to Viacom.  YouTube users thought their online privacy was being invaded so the agreement worked out well for all parties involved.  

                                                                          The copyright issues pertaining to YouTube are still up in the air.  While there is strict language put in place in the site’s Terms of Use page, there is limited enforcement of copyright laws.  There are such a high percentage of videos on the site that are not original content.  People are still getting away with copyright infringement because YouTube is only removing videos that copyright holders order them to take down.  It is doing this is comply with the Digital Millenium Copyright Act.  The act makes certain that illegally uploaded videos be removed if the copyright holders put in the request to do so.  Copyrighted material uploaded to YouTube will remain on the site unless the copyright holder makes the request to have it removed.    

Copyright holders are outraged because the content uploaded illegally is in no way posted for fair use.  YouTube is cashing in on its advertising potential, exploiting copyrighted material all the way to the bank.

One way YouTube has tried to protect itself from more legal trouble has been the creation of what they call the YouTube Video Identification Program.  This program is based on a database of visual constructs of the copyrighted material that copyright holders have requested be protected.  YouTube has been working with the copyright holders to create options of what they can do to the illegally uploaded material.  Depending on the content owner’s preference, YouTube’s Video Identification Program will block the video, promote it or compensate the copyright holder through advertising.  Content holders can choose to partner with YouTube.  Content holders can put ads on their video and receive a minimal fraction of the advertising revenue.  

A new concept that YouTube has just introduced is the ability for users to download videos.  Based on the wishes of the content owners, YouTube will allow users to download certain videos for free or for a small fee paid through Google Checkout.  The partners can set prices and receive a portion of the revenue.  They have been testing this concept with material such as lectures and research from Universities around the nation.

The music industry is heavily involved with the copyright issues surrounding YouTube.  YouTube’s ID program is also being used to identify copyrighted audio tracks uploaded to the site.  For a while, copyright holders to music were given the choice of removing the content from YouTube or using it to generate revenue by adding advertising to it.  Now, YouTube has changed its approach by stripping the sound off the file and leaving the video portion.  This was done as a way to allow users to still post their videos, but protect themselves from copyright issues.  

YouTubers were not happy with the policy because the users who upload the content are having their work destroyed.  An inconceivable number of fan-made videos and remixes will most likely undergo scrutiny by the website at some point.  YouTube has not been thorough in its audio removal because there are still so many more copyright holders who still have not come forward.  The fact that user-created content using unauthorized copyrighted music is being muted has users outraged.  The video is their work and it is being destroyed by copyright holders who feel their work is being infringed upon.

Warner Music Group, the third largest record label, has been unable to come to an agreement with YouTube over renewing the licensing agreement for the label’s music videos.  Warner Music Group stated that they “simply cannot accept terms that fail to appropriately and fairly compensate recording artists, songwriters, labels and publishers for the value they provide.”  The record label could not come to an agreement with YouTube and has begun removing videos belonging to the label.

YouTube is based on users sharing, viewing and creating their own videos with the rest of the YouTube community.  The internet as a whole is making a strong transition of power to the user.  YouTube users are feeling a limit to their freedom with the increase in copyright issues.  It seems to still be a little fuzzy as to what videos are being removed and which ones can stay.  Artists from Warner Music Group have some of their videos removed from the site, while others remain active.  The numbers of videos that are infringing on copyright are high.  However, there are a huge number of videos that have not been modified in any way.  Of course, some of this has to do with the fact that some copyright holders have not taken action against YouTube.  The shift in the way people have been using the internet has changed rapidly in the past decade.  We are seeing more and more legal action being taken by people who believe they are owed money because people are using their content for free.  The Digital Millennium Copyright Act did set the first president for these types of issues, but I expect to see a lot of legal changes made with respect to internet copyright in the near future.