Thursday, April 9, 2009

Tired of Late Fees? Me Too

Netflix has become a movie-renting phenomenon over the past few years.  Consumers are taking full advantage of the Nextflix service, which eliminates many of the negatives associated with the movie rental process.  Renting movies is all about relaxing in the comfort of your home.  Traditionally, it was necessary to drive to your nearest Blockbuster, search the store for a movie, drive home, remember when the movie is due back and bring the flick back before you are charged a late fee.  Netflix takes all this running around out of the game and allows patrons to rent and return movies from home. 

Netflix has 100 shipping points across the nation.  Subscribers can rent movies from home and have them delivered in about one business day.  They can browse among all the available titles and have the movie shipped right to their home.  They can keep the movie for as long as they want.  There are no late fees because subscribers need to return one movie in order to rent a new one.  Netflix makes it easy because they provide the DVD packaging that can be shipped in the mail.

 It seems that the most convenient products and services are becoming the most profitable in many industries.  This has become very apparent in the case of Netflix.  People are too busy in this day in age to be making trips to and from the movie rental storefront.  They are looking for things that cut out wasted time because their minutes are precious.  Nextflix eliminates all of the transportation done by the consumer.  It takes advantage of the reliable mail system to reach its wide customer base.  People also have a lot on their minds, a due date for movie not being one of them.  There is no penalty for people who watch their movies and forget about them for a while.  

Late fees are the most irritating part of the movie rental process.  The fees are necessary for traditional movie rental businesses because without them there is no motivation to return them and their absence from the store becomes lost revenue.  If a movie is not in the store someone else cannot rent it.  Online rentals do not bring in revenue one movie at a time.  The subscription model allows for constant revenue even if one movie is not returned in months.  In fact, it costs less if customers do not return their movies because there is less money spent on the shipments. 

 Netflix also offers over 100,000 DVD titles.  There is a much larger selection online compared to traditional rental stores because they have the room for the movies.  Netflix locations do not need to be arranged in a way that pleases the customers’ eyes.  The locations can be set up for maximum efficiency, which allows them to fit a lot more movies in one location.  

If one business day is too long to wait for a DVD, subscribers can also stream movies straight to a PC or Mac with the necessary system requirements.  Further, Netflix allows users to view the streamed video on their TV’s using a Netflix ready device, which is sold for $99.  This service comes at no additional monthly fee.   

 Netflix has several subscription plans that cater to customers with different needs.  There are three subscription plans that allow for unlimited rentals.  However, each plan has a different price.  The cheapest plan is $8.99 per month and you can have one DVD out at a time.  You have to return your first movie before you can order the next one.  For those who want to have more than one movie out at a time, there are more expensive plans to subscribe to.  The $13.99 per month subscription gives the subscriber a bit more freedom because they can have two movies at once.  The last unlimited subscription plan costs $16.99 per month, which allows subscribers to have three movies out at once.  There is one plan that also offers limited rentals.  The limited plan allows for only two rentals per month and costs only $4.99 per month.  This might be an option for people who like the service, but know that they will not utilize it often.  Here is the breakdown of subscription prices on the website.  

 These subscription plans follow the fixed pricing strategy.  All people subscribing to the same plan are paying the same price per month.  The subscriptions are based on volume pricing, which means that the price of the subscription changes with added features.  The cheapest plan is the limited plan, which only allows for two rentals per month.  The next plan up is only four dollars more per month and gives users unlimited movie rentals throughout the month.  The plans increase in price as more features are added to the packages.  This is not volume pricing in the traditional sense.  Volume pricing is traditionally referred to when you purchase a larger quantity of a product or service for a lower percentage of the original price of the product or service.  For example, if the price to rent one movie is $3 and I can rent five movies for $10.  Volume pricing refers to a selling strategy that gives consumers an incentive to buy more of something.  In the case of Netflix, the incentive to buy more is bumping up their subscription to a more expensive one with more features. 

 Their pricing strategy is a successful one.  Customers are satisfied paying their monthly fee, watching their movies and forgetting about late fees.  The company has skyrocketed as the leader in movie rentals so it has become a win-win between company and consumers.  Online movie renting is becoming the norm and brick and mortar movie rental businesses are having a tough time staying alive.  Many traditional stores have closed in recent years and more stores will close in the future because of this business model.  Blockbuster was falling so far behind Netflix in the industry it had to supplement its traditional business with an online rental business of its own.  Blockbuster’s Total Access Plan is now Netflix number one rival in the industry.  It will integrate its online business with its 8,500.  It could not compete with Netflix in its traditional fashion because the demand for online renting is huge and it’s growing quickly. 

 The fourth quarter financial report for Netflix in 2008 reports that there are about 9,390,000 Netflix subscribers.  This is an increase of 26% from 2007 when there were 7,479,000 subscribers.  Revenue for 2008 was $1.365 billion, up 13% from 2007 when it was $1.205 billion.  Their subscription totals have been increasing rapidly over the past few years and the company has seen a lot of growth since the addition of their service which allows for movies to be streamed directly to subscribers’ computers and TV’s.  The gross margin for 2008 was 33.3%.  They are turning a decent profit with their business.  Blockbuster still leads Netflix in the overall movie rental industry, but Netflix dominates the online sector.  There is a concern felt by all movie rental businesses about the potential for cable TV stations to take over the industry in the future.  The ability for people to order movies on demand is just the beginning.  As the technology increases there is the potential for movie channels to offer subscribers a huge library of movies similar to what Netflix is offering as their online component.  If that technology becomes inexpensive for cable channels to offer the movie rental industry could be in jeopardy.   

Monday, March 16, 2009

Pure-Plays: Leaving Traditional Models Behind


The internet has changed the way business is conducted in 21st century.  With the exception of some Mom and Pop stores still surviving, virtually all businesses have at least a webpage in this day in age.  The age of online shopping began to create a need for businesses to operate, at least in part, online.  There is a larger potential market as more and more people learn how to use the internet.  The opportunities to conduct business online are steadily increasing.  This trend has led to the emergence of web-based business models.  These business models have increased potential compared to traditional business models because they can attract an international audience.  No longer do people shop in the constraints of their own city or even their own state.  Internet users can shop around for different options all over the world.  The internet has allowed for businesses to exist in all areas of the world.  Some of these businesses do not even have a store front to allow for business in its traditional model.  These businesses exist solely on the internet and are called “pure-play” businesses. 

iStockphoto.com is one pure-play business that has seen some success in recent years.  iStockphoto began as a free stock image library site.  Over time, the site has evolved into a successful business that charges users for content based on the amount purchased or on a subscription basis.  iStockphoto is primarily an online library of professional quality photographs.  The library contains nearly 4.5 million images from over 50,000 photographers.  The site’s popularity is growing and the number of photos uploaded to the site is increasing at a rate of 27,000 per week.  More recently, the site has expanded the photography element of the site to offer video, audio, vector illustrations and Flash files.  

Much of the content bought on iStockphoto is used in advertising and promotional projects.  More specifically, you can find work from iStock on product packaging, commercials, catalogues, book covers, newspapers, magazines and electronic publications. 

iStockphoto generates revenue using components of several business models.  Primarily, iStock functions using the Merchant Model.  The company can be considered a virtual merchant because it is selling a product to consumers who can pay the company online for its licensed content.  The merchant model refers to iStock’s “pay-as-you-go credits,” which is a way that people purchase content in moderate portions.  This is done on a company-created system in which people buy a certain number of credits.  Then, each photo is given a specific credit value. 

For instance, one detailed vector image is worth approximately 12 credits.  12 credits is the minimum number of credits you can buy at once and costs $18 USD.  The more credits you buy, the cheaper each credit becomes.  If you buy 50 credits it will cost $70, which means 7% of your credits come as a bonus.  It is a package deal.  As you buy more credits, you pay less for each individual credit.  The highest number of credits you can buy at one time is 2000 for $1,900.  Based on the original price of $18 dollars for 12 credits, this deal gives you 58% of your credits free.  This pay-as-you-go system encourages consumers to buy in large quantities because there is increased value in the package deal.  You get more for your money purchasing in bulk.  Consumers who share that view are helping iStock because they are guaranteeing a larger number of purchases.  The pay-as-you-go system is an effective revenue generating model because it gives consumers an incentive to buy more and pay more.  

Here is an example of a picture from iStockphoto that can be downloaded without payment. Once consumers pay for the pictures they are left with a flawless, professional style photo.  This is the type of picture you get when you don't pay for it.  The site needs to protect its photos so it has this watermark placed over the center of the photo to keep people from using their high quality photos without payment.  

                                      

Another component of iStock’s method to generate revenue is through the Subscription Model.  As an alternative to the credit system, members can sign up for a subscription if they know they will be purchasing content on a larger scale.  Setting up a subscription through the site allows members to set a certain number of credits that can be used in one day ranging from 10 to 480.  Based upon need, members can choose the amount of credits they think they would use on a daily basis.  The subscription can also be customized by length.  A subscription can be set to 3 months, 6 months or 1 year.  There are a number of combinations that members can choose from between the number of credits and length of subscription.  This customization option is very flexible and allows people will all types of schedules and projects to create a subscription that suits them.  Again, these subscriptions are based on package deals.  This means that the more credits you buy and the longer the subscription, the more value you get for each credit. 

Lastly, iStock operates using the Community Model.  The site claims it is “the internet’s original member-generated image and design community.”  Yes, anyone can apply to be a contributing artist to the site, but iStock has a reputation for turning out professional quality work.  Work that does not meet the quality standards is not accepted.  To become a contributing artist to the site, applicants must be tested. 

They must first take a quiz pertaining to site’s policies, requirements and legal issues.  There are many terms that contributors must agree to in order to become a contributor.  The terms of agreement many times deal with important legal issues that contributors should be familiar with.  The site buys and sells protected intellectual property and contributors need to be aware of the issues that could arise.  The site checks to see if the applicants have basic photographic knowledge before they can upload their samples.  Once these tests have been taken care of, the applicants must show proof that they are over 18 years old, or provide a parental consent form allowing them to participate.  If an applicant meets these requirements they are eligible to upload their samples to the site.  Experts analyze the samples and determine if the work is worthy of being sold on the site.  If an applicant is approved he or she may start uploading their work to the site.  Each photo uploaded to the site needs to be inspected for quality and scrutinized for copyright and trademark infringement.

iStock is made up of a community of thousands of artists that upload millions of photos, videos, audio tracks, vector illustrations and Flash files.  It is all user-generated content that is filtered to make sure it is suitable for the site.  Consumers and businesses alike pay good money and expect the work to be professional.  iStock allows these consumers to purchase professional quality work for much cheaper than it would cost to hire a professional photographer.  This pure play business allows contributors from all over the world to upload photos of people from all different cultures.  From the other side of business, the consumer can be purchase iStock  from anywhere around the globe.

                                        

iStock can measure its success in a few ways.  First, it can look to its member community, which is made up of over 3 million members.  This is a significant community sharing content over the internet.  Next, they should look at the number of subscriptions they currently have to see if it is a satisfying number.  They may want to look at past subscribers and see if they are still subscribing or if they have not renewed.  If there are a large number of people who are consistently renewing their subscriptions then they can consider that a success.  If people have stopped subscribing the company should look at ways to contact them and offer them some sort of incentive to renew their subscription.  Email addresses are required as part of the membership.  Writing an email to remind people of an upcoming deal could be all they need to get back into iStock.  They may also want to look at ways that they can increase the number of credits people are buying through subscriptions and pay-as-you-go.  Running promotions to increase credits purchased could increase revenue for the company. 

The fact that pictures are increasing at a rate of 27,000 per week is a good indication that the company is having success.  The company makes a significant commission on each piece of work.  A larger content library for consumers to choose from should retain a higher number of customers because they will have an easier time finding what they are looking for.

iStock is a successful pure-play business.  It exists only on the internet, but it also exists through their 3 million member community.  It exists in the homes and offices of site members.  We are in a new age where transactions do not need to be face to face.  In the case of the iStock contributors, they do not even necessarily see who they are working for.  Contributions, shopping and paying are all done online for this site.  We see a growing number of pure-play’s succeeding in the online world and I anticipate many more in the future.            

 

Monday, February 23, 2009

Will Copyright Laws Get The Best of YouTube?


Virtually anyone who has been living on this planet for the last four years knows that YouTube is one of the most popular and successful websites on the internet.  The website is a video sharing site where users can view, share and upload an unlimited number of videos.  Videos can consist of TV clips, music videos, video blogging, original short films and any video footage users want to share with the world. 

The site, created in February 2005, has since been purchased by Google Inc. for $1.65 billion.  It is now the third most visited website on the internet behind Google and Yahoo!.   People watch hundreds of millions of videos each day.  Currently, it is estimated that ten hours of video is uploaded to YouTube each minute.  The amount of traffic to the site draws many advertisers.  YouTube’s popularity has made them very profitable through their advertising power.  The format of the site allows them to offer a wide variety of advertising options.  Advertisers can run their own video ads, sponsor contests, create their own brand channels or add original content to the site.   

The freedom YouTube allows its users in uploading unlimited video has caused some legal issues for the website.  Users have been uploading copyrighted material to the site without paying royalties to the copyright holder.  This has been the cause of recent lawsuits against the website.  One of the most publicized of these lawsuits came from Viacom, an American media conglomerate, which owns MTV Netowrks, BET, VH-1, Comedy Central, Nickelodeon, Paramount Pictures, DreamWorks and MTV Films to name a few. 

Viacom sued YouTube in 2007, accusing them of “massive intentional copyright infringement.”  Viacom sued for 160,000 unauthorized Viacom clips uploaded to YouTube.  These videos were viewed 1.5 billion times at the time the lawsuit was brought against YouTube.  The Digital Millenium Copyright Act of 1998 was no defense for YouTube, but the judge ruled that Viacom could not seek punitive damages.  Instead, Viacom was able to solicit valuable data about YouTube users.  The court ruled that YouTube had to turn over IP addresses, user names and viewing history of all Viacom videos on the site. 

Later, Viacom and YouTube came to an agreement that allowed YouTube to keep the identities of its users anonymous.  Viacom was already on the defense for invading the privacy of online users so this agreement made Viacom look like a more responsible company.  For YouTube, this agreement kept its users somewhat happier in the situation because they were all kept anonymous.  The names and addresses were not the essential information that was useful to Viacom.  YouTube users thought their online privacy was being invaded so the agreement worked out well for all parties involved.  

                                                                          The copyright issues pertaining to YouTube are still up in the air.  While there is strict language put in place in the site’s Terms of Use page, there is limited enforcement of copyright laws.  There are such a high percentage of videos on the site that are not original content.  People are still getting away with copyright infringement because YouTube is only removing videos that copyright holders order them to take down.  It is doing this is comply with the Digital Millenium Copyright Act.  The act makes certain that illegally uploaded videos be removed if the copyright holders put in the request to do so.  Copyrighted material uploaded to YouTube will remain on the site unless the copyright holder makes the request to have it removed.    

Copyright holders are outraged because the content uploaded illegally is in no way posted for fair use.  YouTube is cashing in on its advertising potential, exploiting copyrighted material all the way to the bank.

One way YouTube has tried to protect itself from more legal trouble has been the creation of what they call the YouTube Video Identification Program.  This program is based on a database of visual constructs of the copyrighted material that copyright holders have requested be protected.  YouTube has been working with the copyright holders to create options of what they can do to the illegally uploaded material.  Depending on the content owner’s preference, YouTube’s Video Identification Program will block the video, promote it or compensate the copyright holder through advertising.  Content holders can choose to partner with YouTube.  Content holders can put ads on their video and receive a minimal fraction of the advertising revenue.  

A new concept that YouTube has just introduced is the ability for users to download videos.  Based on the wishes of the content owners, YouTube will allow users to download certain videos for free or for a small fee paid through Google Checkout.  The partners can set prices and receive a portion of the revenue.  They have been testing this concept with material such as lectures and research from Universities around the nation.

The music industry is heavily involved with the copyright issues surrounding YouTube.  YouTube’s ID program is also being used to identify copyrighted audio tracks uploaded to the site.  For a while, copyright holders to music were given the choice of removing the content from YouTube or using it to generate revenue by adding advertising to it.  Now, YouTube has changed its approach by stripping the sound off the file and leaving the video portion.  This was done as a way to allow users to still post their videos, but protect themselves from copyright issues.  

YouTubers were not happy with the policy because the users who upload the content are having their work destroyed.  An inconceivable number of fan-made videos and remixes will most likely undergo scrutiny by the website at some point.  YouTube has not been thorough in its audio removal because there are still so many more copyright holders who still have not come forward.  The fact that user-created content using unauthorized copyrighted music is being muted has users outraged.  The video is their work and it is being destroyed by copyright holders who feel their work is being infringed upon.

Warner Music Group, the third largest record label, has been unable to come to an agreement with YouTube over renewing the licensing agreement for the label’s music videos.  Warner Music Group stated that they “simply cannot accept terms that fail to appropriately and fairly compensate recording artists, songwriters, labels and publishers for the value they provide.”  The record label could not come to an agreement with YouTube and has begun removing videos belonging to the label.

YouTube is based on users sharing, viewing and creating their own videos with the rest of the YouTube community.  The internet as a whole is making a strong transition of power to the user.  YouTube users are feeling a limit to their freedom with the increase in copyright issues.  It seems to still be a little fuzzy as to what videos are being removed and which ones can stay.  Artists from Warner Music Group have some of their videos removed from the site, while others remain active.  The numbers of videos that are infringing on copyright are high.  However, there are a huge number of videos that have not been modified in any way.  Of course, some of this has to do with the fact that some copyright holders have not taken action against YouTube.  The shift in the way people have been using the internet has changed rapidly in the past decade.  We are seeing more and more legal action being taken by people who believe they are owed money because people are using their content for free.  The Digital Millennium Copyright Act did set the first president for these types of issues, but I expect to see a lot of legal changes made with respect to internet copyright in the near future.  

 

Thursday, January 29, 2009

Customize It

In grade school I remember going to Modell's sporting goods store once a year with my Mom to pick out basketball sneakers for the season.  My Mom always dreaded this day because I was always extremely picky about things; especially sneakers.  It would take what seemed like hours to pick a pair of sneakers I liked because I just couldn't find a pair I was satisfied with.  I remember always narrowing it down to three or four pair before I bought one.  Each one of my finalists would have components that I found attractive, but it was nearly impossible to find that perfect shoe that screamed my name from the display shelf.  

 Now, sneaker companies are using the internet as a way to empower customers.  They are giving customers the opportunity to decide how the company will make a sneaker designed specifically for them.  Buyers can pick a shoe style and begin designing a sneaker from scratch.  They can choose color schemes, designs, materials, personalize text and of course pick their size.  Unfortunately for my Mom, the age of customization struck a decade late. 

 This technology has the ability to change the entire sneaker industry over time.  In years past, sneaker companies would create a new shoe, a few different color schemes and mass produce these designs.  These select designs would hit retail stores and be on display for the public's consumption.  There are only so many shoes you can put on a display wall.  

 This age of customization gives consumers countless combinations of design elements to use in creating a pair of sneakers that individualizes them.  Customizable items are becoming more and more popular because they give consumers a way to represent themselves.  People are more apt to feel connected to something like a sneaker if they had a hand in designing it.  Further, they feel a stronger connection to the brand that allowed them to personalize their product.  It is an empowering feeling to wear something that is self-created.  People communicate through clothing, shoes, accessories and overall appearance.  Customization allows consumers to communicate their uniqueness to everyone within an eye's glance.  Designing a sneaker with all the components approved by the user creates a strong attachment to the product and the brand.  It is a strong emotional connection based on the simple fact that people are proud of things they produce themselves.   

 Two leaders in the sneaker industry are Nike and Puma.  These two companies have separate websites designed specifically for customizing their sneakers.  Nike's website is called NikeiD.  The website is vintage Nike.  You begin by selecting your language followed by your country.  Nike has become so global that they have the site designed so that people across the globe can understand it.  It has the sleek design we have come to expect from Nike.  Because Nike is such dominating force in the shoe industry it has customizable footwear for so many different shoe categories.  Shoe designing is available for all types of athletic shoes, style shoes and classic designs such as the Nike Shox.  

 

One apparent approach displayed on this website is the range of customers Nike is going after.  The website allows for seemingly all Nike customers to find the types of footwear items they use and customize them.  From performance sneakers to cleats to style sneakers, customers can build a shoe that suits them.  The website is targeting various types of people.   

The main screen is split with large images of Kobe Bryant's new basketball shoes and the style sneakers that go after a less athletic crowd.  The basketball side tells site visitors to "customize their game."  This is speaking to basketball players in an attempt to communicate the fact that these shoes will help  identify them as a their own player on the court.  Also, with sports there is always the opportunity to customize for team colors.  Whether coordinating color schemes for a team one plays on or a team one roots for, there is always the option to represent your team.  The other side of this main screen is for the style side of Nike footwear.  This shoe type is for normal everyday use outside of the sports world.  These types of shoes are used to customize your look.  They can be designed to match certain clothing items or just to create a style.  

 The most sought after aspect of this website has to be the number of items that have the potential to be designed.  Simply clicking on the soccer category yields 28 customizable items.  There are many choices of cleats, indoor shoes, performance shirts and bags.  Each one of these items has a different look and style that attracts even more customers.  It is amazing to me how many things you can change on these items.  It goes way beyond creating color schemes to make the shoe look good.  Many options deal with the performance of the shoe.  The soccer cleat for example has the option to choose between an outsole that is better on firm ground or on more sloppy conditions.  To players who know the type of surface they usually play on this is an important option to offer.  Similarly, the baseball cleats have the option between metal and plastic spikes on the bottom of their cleats as most players have a preference between the two.  These types of options are very important ones.  Someone who likes the Nike design of one pair of cleats may buy their cleats elsewhere if Nike does not offer the preferred material on the bottom of that particular cleat design.  The ability to choose everything that goes into your personal product makes for a satisfied customer.  There is no lost business because people cannot find what they are looking for.     

 The first hand experience of the user on Nike's site has so many items to choose from.  Each item is very easily adjustable.  You can click on any piece of the shoe and it will immediately show the options for changing that piece of the shoe.  In addition, there is also a pull down menu, which lets the user go through the design process step by step.  It is an organized way of designing it, but the option to click on one section of the shoe at a time is convenient.  This is the new Kobe Bryant shoe I designed using the NikeiD site.  

 

In addition to being easily adapted, the shoe designs are encouraged to be shared.  There are applications allowing users to share their design with friends on both Facebook and MySpace.  For friends who are not on these social networks, it allows you to email the link of the design.  Anywhere the design is shared there is a link back to the website to view the design.  This is a great way to drive traffic and get more people exposed to the site.  In addition, it allows customers to create wallpaper on their computer featuring their sneaker design.  There is so much a customer can do with his or her design that it makes the process a lot more fun.  This will encourage them to use the site more frequently.   

Puma's approach is very different than that of Nike.  The company is going for an Asian Restaurant theme, which is very disconnected to the brand in my opinion.  According to Puma, the Mongolian BBQ originated from Ghengis Khan's army in the Far East.  They soldiers used their swords to prepare cuts of meats and vegetables to be cooked in their shields.  The only solid connection between the Mongolians and the Puma shoe customization business is the fact that they both use many "ingredients."  

 

The site entrance features an Asian chef in a restaurant with the caption "Grab your chef hat and preheat your creativity."  The website alludes to this Asian cuisine theme repeatedly.  It plays with words explaining that everyone has different "tastes."  Puma has a "menu" of traditional Puma sneakers to choose from and all the essential "ingredients" to create a unique sneaker.  For me, this theme does not at all connect to the brand.  I understand they were playing off the fact that a shoe is made up of many ingredients and there are many metaphors that this theme allows, but it takes away from Puma as a shoe company. 

Overall, the site is much simpler than Nike's.  They have a lot going on with the BBQ theme, but there is not nearly as much content.  This has to do with the fact that Puma only offers three shoe styles on its "menu," while Nike offers 28 on its soccer division alone.  However, the actual design process on the Puma site is much more in-depth, which allows for more customization per shoe.  The shoe I designed on the Puma website had 17 steps, which the shoe I designed on the Nike site was only 13.  There were some items on the Nike site that had as little as 7 steps depending on the item.  

 The process for designing a shoe on the Puma site was much more organized and structured.  However, the convenience of clicking on a section of the shoe to change is absent on Puma's site.  Users can only customize their shoes from the scroll tab.  The large scroll tab on the right side took the user from step to step.  The more generalized steps are broken down into the side, top and back of the shoe.  Then there were a number of steps inside these categories.  This allowed you to think about the design in a more linear progression.  The Nike design was more disorganized because all its steps were thrown together and jumped around the shoe.  

 

Puma also encouraged the sharing of designs, but downplayed it somewhat.  It had a small share button that allowed you to share your design on Facebook, but that was it.  Aside from the vast customization options, Puma's site is quite dull and I am completely thrown by the Asian cuisine theme.  It does not resonate with brand and really takes away from the great customization features.  

 To close, I would like to say that Puma's customization site allowed for a more organized way to customize their shoes.  The steps were laid out in a way that made more sense for me.  Also, the number of customization options on the shoe surpassed that of Nike, which I do believe is relevant.  Puma paid more attention to detail in the customizing process allowing to change intricate things including the color of stitching on the rubber sole and the inside of the tongue.  These intricate designs add something for me as a consumer.  The more I can control the better.  

 Nike also has its strengths.  It continues to stick with its consistent image on its NikeiD site, which helps to integrate all the brand components.  Nike's number of customizable items is a valuable asset.  It gives consumers many choices, which can increase the number of customers.  The convenience in designing the shoe is helpful.  People want things to be easy and making the designing process simple for people is an attractive feature.  Also, the applications including the sharing on two social networks and the wallpaper feature give added value to the site.  People want to share their work and Nike allows them to do so. 

Overall, I would say that Puma has the better way of customizing shoes.  The layout, options and small details give Puma the edge in customization.  However, Nike creates the better customer experience.  There are more items to browse through, specialty items for specific sports and more convenience in the design process.  Half the fun in designing a shoe on these sites is being able to show others what you can create.  The ability to share designs through multiple sources gives Nike the edge.  Nike uses technology better than Puma and allows customers a better experience on the website.